Showing posts with label Investing. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Investing. Show all posts

May 16, 2008

Money In Disease

Interesting article from the Economist about a new focus by pharmaceutical companies on developing countries. The standard operating procedure for most drug companies has been to market drugs to developed countries, where the population could afford the medication. Or they have developed niche products which cost a lot of money per dosage.

Over the past couple of years, emerging market countries have either created generic versions of the drugs marketed by Big Pharma, or just outright copied their drugs ignoring any patent protection. Most of the pharmaceutical companies have just ignored these developing countries.

That attitude may be changing due to these countries expanding middle class. 'McKinsey, a consultancy, estimates that the value of the Indian drugs market will grow from $6.3 billion in 2005 to $20 billion in 2015. China's market is expected to soar even more spectacularly. Given such prospects for growth, says Mark Feinburg of Merck, an American drugs giant, “you've got to be in these markets—it's a great opportunity.”'

To the right is a graph from the Economist showing the major causes of deaths in China, India & Brazil. The graph is not clear on what the percentage of minor deaths are, but looking at the percentages of the Big C's (Cardiovascular, Cancer, Chronic and Communicable) there is a lot of opportunity to sell some medication.

The three countries in the graph equal 2.6 billion people with a total GDP of $12 trillion dollars, growing at 8%. Developed countries (US, EU & Japan) have a population of 127 million, but a total GDP of $34 trillion dollars, growing at 2%. The developed countries are fairly saturated when it comes to the pharmaceutical market. However the market in the emerging economies is still under-served.

The Economist explains that for foreign companies tapping into these markets its not just as easy as opening a factory and selling drugs.

'Serving these markets will mean building up local expertise and research efforts. Where drugs firms have set up shop in developing markets, it has generally been to cut costs, rather than to cater to the needs of locals. But that is changing. Novartis has opened a research centre in Shanghai and has another outpost in Singapore focused on tropical diseases. Merck has struck several deals with firms in emerging markets to do early-stage research. The drugs giants argue that this new approach allows them to tap a global network of innovation, and also provides insights into local markets.'

Source:
'Quagmire To Goldmine ?', by The Economist
The World Fact Book, by The CIA

May 15, 2008

Don't Mess With Carl

In a letter sent to Yahoo's board, Carl Ichann has threaten to seek control of the board, if it doesn't renew talks with Microsoft. Below is the first paragraph from his letter.

'It is clear to me that the board of directors of Yahoo has acted irrationally and lost the faith of shareholders and Microsoft. It is quite obvious that Microsoft's bid of $33 per share is a superior alternative to Yahoo's prospects on a standalone basis. I am perplexed by the board's actions. It is irresponsible to hide behind management's more than overly optimistic financial forecasts. It is unconscionable that you have not allowed your shareholders to choose to accept an offer that represented a 72% premium over Yahoo's closing price of $19.18 on the day before the initial Microsoft offer. I and many of your shareholders strongly believe that a combination between Yahoo and Microsoft would form a dynamic company and more importantly would be a force strong enough to compete with Google on the Internet.'

Clearly Mr Ichann motives are driven by money, but he is saying what a lot of people were thinking. What was Yahoo thinking? I am sure that Yahoo thinks that they can go it alone, but what does it have to offer beyond the internet? The buy-out offers gives everyone at Yahoo a nice and neat way out of the business.

Goggle is eating every one's lunch when it comes to making money online, along with developing innovate ways to sell advertising space. Just this week, comScore announced that Google beat out Yahoo for the first time in the number of unique visitors with 141 million views. Yahoo was second with 140 million and third was MSN at 121 million. When it comes to the share of online searches, Google has 59.2% of the market followed by Yahoo at 21.6% and MSN at 9.6%.

Below is a chart of Google, Apple, Yahoo & Microsoft over the past year.

Source: yahoo.com

If Ichann gains control of the board, and Microsoft doesn't want to buy the whole company, will there be more value in breaking up Yahoo?

Source:
'Icahn Threatens Yahoo Board Fight After Failed Bid', by Crayton Harrison, Bloomberg News
'Google Sites Capture #1 Property Ranking for the First Time', by comScore.com

April 28, 2008

Investment Definitions - Part 2

More definitions for investors to be aware of. Most of your money is made when you buy a stock (or other type of investments), and using a limit or a stop order will help you purchase a stock at the price you want.

Limit Order - is an order to buy or sell a security at a specific price. A buy limit order can only be executed at the limit price or lower, and a sell limit order can only be executed at the limit price or higher. When you place a market order, you can't control the price at which your order will be filled.

For example, if you want to buy the stock of a "hot" IPO that was initially offered at $9, but don't want to end up paying more than $20 for the stock, you can place a limit order to buy the stock at any price up to $20. By entering a limit order rather than a market order, you will not be caught buying the stock at $90 and then suffering immediate losses if the stock drops later in the day or the weeks ahead.

Remember that your limit order may never be executed because the market price may quickly surpass your limit before your order can be filled. But by using a limit order you also protect yourself from buying the stock at too high a price. Some firms may charge you more for executing a limit order than a market order.

Market Order - is an order to buy or sell a stock at the current market price. Unless you specify otherwise, your broker will enter your order as a market order.

The advantage of a market order is you are almost always guaranteed your order will be executed (as long as there are willing buyers and sellers). Depending on your firm’s commission structure, a market order may also be less expensive than a limit order.

The disadvantage is the price you pay when your order is executed may not always be the price you obtained from a real-time quote service or were quoted by your broker. This may be especially true in fast-moving markets where stock prices are more volatile. When you place an order "at the market," particularly for a large number of shares, there is a greater chance you will receive different prices for parts of the order.

Stop Order - is an order to buy or sell a stock once the price of the stock reaches a specified price, known as the stop price. When the specified price is reached, your stop order becomes a market order.

The advantage of a stop order is you don't have to monitor how a stock is performing on a daily basis. The disadvantage is that the stop price could be activated by a short-term fluctuation in a stock's price. Also, once your stop price is reached, your stop order becomes a market order and the price you receive may be much different from the stop price, especially in a fast-moving market where stock prices can change rapidly. An investor can avoid the risk of a stop order not guaranteeing a specific price by placing a stop-limit order.

Buy Stop Order - investors typically use a stop order when buying stock to limit a loss or protect a profit on short sales. The order is entered at a stop price that is always above the current market price.

Sell Stop Order - a sell stop order helps investors to avoid further losses or to protect a profit that exists if a stock price continues to drop. A stop order to sell is always placed below the current market price.

Stop Limit Order - is an order to buy or sell a stock that combines the features of a stop order and a limit order. Once the stop price is reached, the stop-limit order becomes a limit order to buy or to sell at a specified price.

The benefit of a stop-limit order is that the investor can control the price at which the trade will get executed. But, as with all limit orders, a stop-limit order may never get filled if the stock's price never reaches the specified limit price. This may happen especially in fast-moving markets where prices fluctuate wildly.

See my earlier post with additional definitions.

Source:
'
Orders', SEC.gov

April 18, 2008

Investment Definitions

A couple of definitions all investors should be aware of:

  • Correlation - is the extent to which the values of different types of investments move in tandem with one another in response to changing economic and market conditions. Correlation is measured on a scale of -1 to +1. Investments with a correlation of +.5 or more tend to rise and fall in value at the same time. Investments with a negative correlation of -.5 to -1 are more likely to gain or lose value in opposing cycles.

  • Sharpe Ratio - used to compare the relationship of risk and reward in following different investment strategies, such as emphasizing growth or value investments, or in holding different combinations of investments. To figure the ratio, the risk-free return is subtracted from the average return of an investment portfolio over a period of time, and the result is divided by the standard deviation of the return. A strategy with a higher ratio is less risky than one with a lower ratio. This type of analysis, which is done using sophisticated computer programs, is named for William P. Sharpe, who won the Nobel Prize in economics in 1990.

  • Beta - is a measure of an investment's relative volatility. The higher the beta, the more sharply the value of the investment can be expected to fluctuate in relation to a market index. For example, Standard & Poor's 500-stock Index (S&P 500) has a beta coefficient (or base) of 1. That means if the S&P 500 moves 2% in either direction, a stock with a beta of 1 would also move 2%. Under the same market conditions, however, a stock with a beta of 1.5 would move 3% (2% increase x 1.5 beta = 0.03, or 3%). But a stock with a beta lower than 1 would be expected to be more stable in price and move less. Betas as low as 0.5 and as high as 4 are fairly common, depending on the sector and size of the company. However, in recent years, there has been a lively debate about the validity of assigning and using a beta value as an accurate predictor of stock performance.

  • Asset Allocation - is a strategy, advocated by modern portfolio theory, for reducing risk in your investment portfolio in order to maximize return. Specifically, asset allocation means dividing your assets among different broad categories of investments, called asset classes. Stock, bonds, and cash are examples of asset classes, as are real estate and derivatives such as options and futures contracts. Most financial services firms suggest particular asset allocations for specific groups of clients and fine-tune those allocations for individual investors. The asset allocation model — specifically the percentages of your investment principal allocated to each investment category you’re using — that’s appropriate for you at any given time depends on many factors, such as the goals you’re investing to achieve, how much time you have to invest, your tolerance for risk, the direction of interest rates, and the market outlook. Ideally, you adjust or rebalance your portfolio from time to time to bring the allocation back in line with the model you’ve selected. Or, you might realign your model as your financial goals, your time frame, or the market situation changes.

Source:
Glossary, Yahoo Finance

April 14, 2008

Stock or Industry Selection

A paper published by Jeffery A Busse and Qing Tong, of the Goizueta Business School at Emory University, explains that for consistent performance in a mutual fund its better to have a manager who can pick industry sectors than one who can pick stocks. The paper explains 'that industry selection contributes substantially to fund performance, accounting for roughly half of a fund's abnormal performance.' The paper states that this importance of industry selection is 'stable across time, with little year-to-year variation in the mean contribution across funds.'

The paper is based on analyzing almost 4,000 actively managed domestic mutual funds from 1980 to 2006. The researchers analyzed a manager's industry selection ability by setting up a hypothetical portfolio which replaced each stock in the fund with an index for that stock's industry. For example if a manager bought Johnson and Johnson, the researchers added an equal dollar amount of an index representing major drug manufacturers. If the hypothetical portfolio beat the market, the manager was showed to be good at industry selection. If the manager's stock picks outperformed the hypothetical portfolio, the manager was judged to be good at stock selection.

Based on the analysis, the researchers found that a manager's margin for beating the market was split almost evenly between stock selection and industry selection. However, over a longer period of time, industry selection was a skill that would most likely persist. The paper also found 'a negative relation between fund portfolio size and stock-selection skill'. This 'negative relation' was not present when comparing the size of a fund and industry selection. This fact probably explains why some large mutual funds preform quite well, while others suffer.

Below is a chart comparing Fidelity's Magellan Fund (market cap $38.40 billion) to American Funds Growth Fund of America ($165 billion). Between 1977 and 1990, the Magellan Fund, under the management of Peter Lynch, had an annualized returned of 29%. The fund ran into problems in the late 90's when the funds asset base swell to $100 billion dollars and ended up a 'closet' index fund. As the fund grew, the manager was unable to put that money to work effectively. Stock selection which had been the strong suit of the fund's new manager broke down under the weight of its asset base.

Source: bigcharts.com
On the other hand the Growth Fund of America, has an annualized return of 13% compared to 8.2% for the S&P 500 over the past 10 years. This fund has been successful due to its management structure and sector selection. Rather than relying on one manager, or even a team of in-house managers, it is managed by multiple management teams. This structure has allowed it to grow, while still preforming better than the market. Granted that at $165 billion, this fund will probably have a difficult time maintaining its returns, and will probably end up mimicking the returns of the market. (How large is too large?)
Below is a chart of Van Wagoner Emerging Growth Fund (market cap $15 million) compared to the Russell 2000. In the mid to late 1990s, the Emerging Growth Fund was returning 50% plus returns each quarter by investing in small-cap technology stocks. However, since 1995 the fund has an annualized return of -7.8%. You would have made more money leaving it under your mattress.
Source: bigcharts.com
The funds dismal returns are due to stock picking, and industry selection. The fund focused on small-cap stocks in the technology sector, not the best place to be since the Internet bubble popped in 2000.
Source:
'Mutual Fund Industry Selection and Persistence', By Jeffery A Busse and Qing Tong
'Picking the Forest or the Trees', by Mark Hulbert, NY Times

April 11, 2008

Dollar Cost Average or Lump Sum

Dollar cost averaging or lump sum, which is the best approach for an investor. The unequivocal answer is either one depending on your situation.

Basic Investment Strategies

Below is a brief explanation of the two investment strategies. Have also thrown in another strategy that is similar to dollar cost averaging.

Dollar Cost Averaging (DCA) is defined as the investment strategy of buying a fixed dollar amount of a particular investment on a regular schedule, regardless of the share price. More shares are purchased when prices are low, and fewer shares are bought when prices are high. An example of this type of investing is to purchase $1,000 of shares each month to in a mutual fund for a total of $12,000 over a year.

Lump Sum Investing (LSI) is defined as the investment strategy of buying a particular investment at one time. An example of this type of investing is entering in an order to purchase $12,000 worth of shares at a single time. Typically additional purchases would not be made in a significant amount.

Value Averaging (VA) is defined as an investing strategy that works much like dollar cost averaging (DCA) in terms of steady monthly contributions, but differs in its approach to the amount of each monthly contribution. In value averaging, the investor sets a target growth rate or amount on his or her asset base or portfolio each month, and then adjusts the next month's contribution according to the relative gain or shortfall made on the original asset base. An example of this type of investing is to start by purchasing a set number of shares, and over a period of a time purchasing additional shares each month so that the account value equals $12,000. The number of shares would vary depending on the price of the shares. Months when the price is lower than the intital purchase price, more shares would be bought and the opposite when prices are higher.

Which Strategy Yields The Best Returns?

Using historical data to compare the DCA strategy to the LSI strategy, the LSI method returns higher results 2 out of 3 times. Here is a tool that allows you to test the two methods for each month of the year since 1950. LSI has the advantage since the overall trend of the stock market has been to increase in value year to year. In a rising stock market, DCA is hurt by the fact that with each purchase the cost basis of the shares increases while the LSI cost basis remains constant. Typically in a market that is in a down trend, the DCA strategy comes out ahead because with each purchase the cost basis is lowered.

Below is a chart from AllFinancialMatters.com, that compares DCA strategy to LSI strategy. The LSI strategy (account value) took $19,900 and invested in the Vanguard S&P 500 Index fund on January 2, 1990. The DCA strategy invested $100 at the begining of each month from January 2, 1990 to July 3, 2006, which works out to a total of $19,900 (199 months multipled by $100 each month).

Practical Advice

If you come into a large amount of money and want to invest it, you are better off putting it on all at one time. First is the evidence clearly shows that in most cases you will come out ahead by lump-sum investing. Secondly if you invest it all at one time, you will not be tempted to spend it.

Most of us cannot afford to take a large sum of money at one time and invest it, by default we have to dollar-cost average. An employee sponsered retirement plan (401K or 403B) is a perfect example of dollar-cost averaging. If this is the only way that you can afford to invest, this is your best option.

Source:
'Dollar Cost Averaging', Investopedia.com
'Value Averaging', Investopedia.com
'
Dollar Cost Averaging v. Lump Sum Investing - Part II', by JLP, allfinancialmatters.com
'Lump Sum Beats Dollar-Cost Averaging' by Richard E. Williams, Ph.D., and Peter W. Bacon, DBA, CFP, Journal of Financial Planning

April 10, 2008

Simple Investment Advice

There is a ton of information and advice out there on how to build wealth. It seems that some people try to attain wealth by developing a 'system' on how to be rich, then write a book on the 'system' and finally give seminars on how the 'system' works. A long the way there are plenty of opportunities for selling 'system' merchandise. The problem with this is that each 'system' needs a little different angle to make it stand out from all the other stuff out there. All of these different angles end up creating a lot of noise and confusion, when really most systems talk about the same basic things.

I guess if I were to write a book on how to build wealth I would write about these six pieces of advice. Eventually I will have to come up with a fancy buzz word, which would be trademarked, to describe my powerful wealth building system, but these things just seem like common sense.

Just think, I have already started you on your way to building your wealth. By finding this you just saved $9.99 plus tax for my book.

1. Start Now

The sooner you start to invest the better your long term returns will be due to the power of time (and compounding). Time is one of the best investment tools you will ever have. Below is a chart, from AG Edwards, that compares an early saver and a late saver. The early saver deposits $250 a month for 10 years for a total investment of $30,000, while the late saver waits 10 years and then begins to deposit $250 a month for 30 years for a total investment of $90,000. Assuming an 8% compounded return and ignoring taxes, at the end of 40 years the early saver has $88,000 more than the late saver. If the earlier saver continued to save $250 a month for the entire 40 years the difference between the two savers would be much greater.

Source: AGEdwards.com

Don't worry about the hottest stocks or sectors to be in. Don't worry about not having enough money to begin. Don't worry about being too young or too old. Don't worry about how much you need to save. Just start.

2. Compounding is Your Friend

Albert Einstein has been quoted as saying "The most powerful force in the universe is compound interest." In the case of investing in stocks and mutual funds you are really compounding your returns, but the idea is similar to compound interest. As you reinvest your dividends and capital gains distributions back into your stocks or mutual funds, this reinvestment generates additional earnings which grow year after year. Below is a chart, from Bankrate.com, showing that if at age 25 you started to put $100 per month into an account that returns 6% each year that you would have $200,145.

Source: Bankrate.com

The great thing about compounding is that the growth you get from reinvesting the dividends and capital gains distributions will start to outpace the return you get from your initial investment. Think of it as a small snowball rolling down a mountain. As the snowball rolls down the hill it picks up more and more snow, building in size. At the bottom of the mountain the snowball has grown in size to a massive one (a bit of an exaggeration but you get the idea). Eventually you reach a point where your money is working for you to create more money. This is the 'holy grail' for investors.

3. Your Only Average

You should just come out and say this 'I am not as good of an investor as I think I am'. Numerous studies have been performed showing that people tend to be overly optimistic when it comes to investment decisions. This over optimism leads people to sell their winning investments too soon and hold onto their losing investments too long. If you are able to take the emotion out of your investing, and accept that you are only average you will come out ahead of many others. From a NY Times article:

Stocks have been a great investment in the last 80 years, with an average return of about 10 percent a year. But have investors in the stock market done as well as stocks? Surprisingly, the answer is no. The average dollar invested in the stock market in those years has earned only about 8.6 percent a year.

The article references a paper published by Ilia D. Dichev, a University of Michigan accounting professor, that explains the difference due to investors buying patterns. The article provides an example:

To understand the difference between a stock’s return and an investor’s return, consider someone who buys 100 shares of a company at a price of $10 a share. A year later, the share price is up to $20, and the investor buys 100 more shares.

Alas, the investor’s luck has run out. By the end of the next year, the price has fallen back to $10 and the investor sells his 200 shares. A buy-and-hold investor who bought at $10, held the stock for two years, and then sold at $10 would have had a zero return.

But our friend who tried to time the market did much worse: over the two years, he invested $3,000 in the stock and ended up with only $2,000. Even though the stock broke even, the investor lost money because of bad timing: most of his money was invested right before the market fell.

To calculate a meaningful measure of the investor’s return, it is necessary to weight the yearly returns by the dollars invested during that year. When Mr. Dichev calculates the dollar-weighted returns on this stock according to his preferred method, our hypothetical investor’s average yearly return ends up being negative 26.8 percent, far below the zero return that the buy-and-hold investor would have received.

4. Invest for The Long Term / Invest Through All Markets

Shorter time periods in the stock market are very volatile, however the general trend for most stock markets has been in an upward direction. The market will fluctuate from day to day, month to month and year to year, the market can not be up making a new high everyday.

Source: yahoo.com

Above is a chart of the S&P 500 starting in 1950 through today, compared to the 10-year US Bond. Since 1950 there have been 12 bear markets with an average loss of -26%. Over the same period the S&P 500 has returned over 7,500%. During those 12 bear markets it probably seemed like the world was ending, however the market rebounded from these events. Granted markets do not go up all the time and there maybe periods of under performance, however being invested in the stock market is a great way to build wealth.

5. Keep It Simple, Be Lazy

There is no need to spend a lot of time developing a complex portfolio of stock, bond and mutual fund holdings. The easiest way to be invested in the market and to be diversified is to invest in a Life Style or Target Retirement fund. These types of funds are a one-stop-fund that invest in a basket of stock and bond mutual funds, shifting overtime from more stocks in the early years to more bonds as the 'target' age is reached. These funds will even re-balance as needed to maintain their asset allocations, all you would need to do is fund the investment. Granted these types of investments are not a lot of fun to talk about at a cocktail party, but in the long run they will save you time, effort and worry. Below is a chart comparing a very simple portfolio (Second Garder's Starter), a target retirement fund (T Rowe Price 2040 Fund) and the S&P 500.

Portfolio

Equity %

1 Year Return (3)

3 Year Annualized Return (3)

5 Year Annualized Return (3)

Second Grader's Starter (1)

90%

8.83%

12.31%

17.02%

S&P 500 (1)

100%

5.49%

8.62%

12.83%

T Rowe Price 2040 Fund (2)

91%

6.67%

10.31%

14.76%

1) Source: Morningstar Inc
2) Source: T Rowe Price
3) Returns as of 01/03/2008

For more information see my posts on being a lazy investor, part one and part two.

6. Make It Automatic

Sign up for an automatic investment plan. The most common of these plans is a 401K or other employee-sponsored retirement plan you might find at work. These plans work by automatically taking money from your pay check and investing them into your account. You don't even get a chance to spend the money. You are paying yourself first.

Another great thing about automatic investment plans is that you are dollar-cost averaging (DCA). Dollar cost averaging is a 'technique of buying a fixed dollar amount of a particular investment on a regular schedule, regardless of the share price. More shares are purchased when prices are low, and fewer shares are bought when prices are high.'

There is some controversy about DCA and that it is nothing more than a marketing gimmick. Some studies have shown that over 'long periods, dollar-cost averaging almost always produces lower returns than investing lump sums in diversified portfolios, and almost never reduces risk meaningfully.' The studies are correct, if one were able to invest lump sums they would come out ahead, but who has a nice lump sum sitting around?

Probably the most important lesson to take away is that it takes discipline and commitment to build wealth. Very few people are lucky enough to win the lottery, to have developed and marketed a must-have gadget or worked hard starting their own company which has been bought out for millions of dollars. Most of us have the save and invest diligently, live within or means and let time help us out. But it is possible if you just start now.

Source:
'Sometimes the Stock Does Better Than the Investor That Buys the Stock',by Hal R Varian, New York Times
'Dollar-Cost Averaging', Investopedia.com
'The costly myth of dollar-cost averaging', by Timothy Middleton, MSNMoney.com

April 9, 2008

What A Decade

Seems that the period from 1998/1999 to today has been a terrible time to be either an employee or a stock investor.

Wages Down

The graph below is from a NY Times article talking about how many Americans did not get a head during the boom of the last decade. At the end of 2000 the median (or typical) American Family made about $61,000. At the end of 2007 the estimated median income was $60,500. These numbers are from the Census Bureau and have been adjusted for inflation via the NY Times article.

The article goes onto explain that, "(t)his has never happened before, at least not for as long as the government has been keeping records. In every other expansion since World War II, the buying power of most American families grew while the economy did.'

'More than anything else — more than even the war in Iraq — the stagnation of the great American middle-class machine explains the glum national mood today. As part of a poll that will be released Wednesday, the Pew Research Center asked people how they had done over the last five years. During that time, remember, the overall economy grew every year, often at a good pace."

"Yet most respondents said they had either been stuck in place or fallen backward. Pew says this is the most downbeat short-term assessment of personal progress in almost a half century of polling.'

The average American family has also been battered around by the end of the technology bubble in 2000 and the collapse of the housing market in 2006/2007. They have also had to deal with increases in food and gas prices making it hard to feed a family and fill up the car. No wonder the outlook is so downbeat.

Stocks Down

Below is a graph from a WSJ article talking about the stock markets lost decade. Since 1999, the S&P has returned just 1.3% a year over the past decade. This return takes into account inflation and dividends. You would have made more money by investing in the US Long-Term Treasury Bonds (7.68%) over the same period.

The article explains some of this under-performance due to after a period of "extraordinary returns, as we did from 1982 through 1999, then usually the next 10 years aren't very good," says Prof. Sylla. His research suggests that exceptional booms steal gains from the future. When the booms end, returns become subpar, so that average returns over the longer term fall back to the 7% norm. Economists call this "reversion to the mean," the idea that exceptional performance can't last forever.'

Don't look for a quick recovery either:

"We have to accept that this is no longer a nation of 4% real economic growth. This is a mature nation that no longer has a strong manufacturing base," says Steve Leuthold, chairman of Leuthold Weeden Research in Minneapolis. He believes that another bull market is on the horizon, perhaps following some additional stock declines. But that future bull market, he contends, could be followed by another bear market that could bring stocks back close to where they are today."

"Before another lengthy bull run can begin, stocks need to overcome two problems: the hangover from the high prices of the late 1990s, and the continuing effects of the exceptionally low interest rates instituted by the Federal Reserve in 2001 and again today. Those low interest rates helped push corporate profits higher, but also fueled borrowing excesses that led to today's economic problems."

Both articles are a good, if depressing, read.

Source:
'For Many, a Boom That Wasn’t', by David Leonhardt, NY Times
Stocks Tarnished By 'Lost Decade', E. S. Browning, WSJ {$$$}

April 4, 2008

You Are Born A Sucker

Or at least that is what behavioral economists think. Below is an interview with Dan Ariely, a behavioral economist with posts at MIT and Duke, from Money Magazine. Ariely has a new book out 'Predictably Irrational: The Hidden Forces That Shape Our Decisions'.

Question: What's one of our biggest, most illogical weaknesses as consumers?

A. "Free" offers. When the price of something is said to be zero, it blinds us. We get so excited, we fail to realize that we'll end up paying in some way.

Question: For instance?

A. When I bought a car a few years ago, I debated between two choices. One was less practical but had a special deal going for it: free oil changes for three years. This sealed the decision for me. Later I realized that since I don't drive much, it was only $150 to $200 in savings. And in the end I was left with a less practical car.

Also, one Halloween I gave a bunch of trick-or-treaters two Hershey's Kisses, then told them they could have a small Snickers for free or a huge Snickers for the price of one chocolate kiss. The bigger bar was a better deal, an 8-to-1 return on chocolate. But most chose the smaller one; the idea of getting something for nothing was too tempting.

Question: How else do we act against our best interests?

A. By comparing prices on similar items.

Question: Wait, I thought that was smart to do.

A. It is, but only if you compare everything with everything. If you just compare items near one another, you open yourself up to being influenced. When you open a menu at a restaurant, you may not realize that the prices you see affect what you're willing to pay.

If the most expensive entrée is $45, you might decide $30 is an acceptable price. Should the restaurant add a $60 dish, you may be willing to pay $45. The same issue comes up when shopping for real estate. Letting a broker show you a house above the top of your range can be costly.

Question: So how do we overcome irrationality?

A. There's no cure-all. But when I see the word free, I now ask myself, "What's the seller trying to do here?" Also, it sounds strange, but try not to look at price, not at first. Decide what you want and what you're willing to pay without being influenced by outside factors.

Source:
'Why you're a big sucker', by Paul J. Lim, Money Magazine

April 1, 2008

Are Commodities The Next Bubble?

Over the weekend Barron's had an article on the boom in commodities markets and that it is probably about to suffer a correction. The article stated that most of the rise in the commodity markets are due to ETFs and Mutual Funds (MF) which are exempt from position limitations put in place by the CFTC (Commodity Futures Trading Commission). These limitations (for every long position there is a short position) are in place to protect the market from excessive speculation due to the limited size of the markets.

The ETF and MF money (every $9 out of $10) is not directly invested with the commodity exchanges, but with dealers that belonging to the International Swaps and Derivatives Association (ISDA). The dealers act as market makers for the commodity markets that the ETFs & MFs are investing in, by hedge the risk they have incurred back onto the commodity markets. What happens when all of the dumb money wants to sell their ETF or MF after the market drops 10-20%? There is too much leverage in the market to facilitate an orderly exit for all of these positions. Below is a chart providing a snap shot of the commodity markets and positions.

A Sucker's Bet

The Barron's article provides a nice little synopses of the issue:

'Here's the problem: The speculators' bullishness may be way overdone, in the process lifting prices far above fair value. If the speculators were to follow the commercial players -- the farmers, the food processors, the energy producers and others who trade daily in the physical commodities -- they'd be heading for the exits. For right now, the commercial players are betting on price declines more heavily than ever before...'

The ETFs & MF have taken almost 60% of the bullish (long) positions. Most commercial dealers have taken bearish (short) positions, betting against the continued rise in prices. These short positions are running almost 30% higher than the previous net-short record in March of 2004. The commercial dealers are the guys who have been in this business for a long time and have seen boom and bust cycles. It would make sense to watch what they are doing.

Everything I Know About Trading, I Learned From the Movies

How many times do you get to quote 'Trading Places' ?

Louis Winthorpe III: Think big, think positive, never show any sign of weakness. Always go for the throat. Buy low, sell high. Fear? That's the other guy's problem. Nothing you have ever experienced will prepare you for the absolute carnage you are about to witness. Super Bowl, World Series - they don't know what pressure is. In this building, it's either kill or be killed. You make no friends in the pits and you take no prisoners. One minute you're up half a million in soybeans and the next, boom, your kids don't go to college and they've repossessed your Bentley. Are you with me?


Billy Ray Valentine: Yeah, we got to kill the motherf... - we got to kill 'em!

Will It Last?

From Barron's, 'Index funds offer investors an easy, inexpensive way to gain exposure to a segment of the commodities markets or a broad-based basket of commodities. Result: The funds have drawn many private investors who have never ventured into futures, along with pension funds and other institutional players looking to diversify. But for all the virtues that the funds hold as a way of spreading bets across commodity markets, they take only long, or bullish, positions, avoiding short-selling. In other words, they trade on the naïve and potentially fatal assumption that commodities have the same tendency as stocks to rise over the long run.'

No and yes. In the short term think that the speculative money will run out at the first signs of trouble. The commodity market experienced a 5-10% drop in prices during the past two weeks, but has firmed up. Looking at the charts above, due to the drop in prices it looks like some of the speculative money has started to leave, or at least some have taken profits. Things that might cause the bubble to pop are:

  • China / India - these countries have experienced a high rate of economic growth. Any slow down in this growth will affect commodity prices.
  • Dollar - the dollar is at historic lows. Commodities are priced in dollars making it easier for other currencies to buy more of the commodities. If the dollar increases in value this discrepancy is negated.
  • US - most consumers are spending on goods from China. If the US consumer starts to reduce their spending this will effect the demand for raw materials to make those goods.
  • Lack of Buying - who is left to buy? Once there is a lack of buyers, the market will start to fall due to its own weight.

Long term commodities are a bullish bet. The earth's population is not getting any smaller and certain commodities are non-renewable. This sounds like a sweet spot for oil and natural gas companies. Also as more land is taken out of farm use due to urban/suburban development, whats left will become more valuable along with whatever it produces. Agribusiness sounds like a great thing to be involved in. In the words of Jim Rogers:

`If I told you how bullish I am about agriculture, you'd ask me to leave the room. Prices of agricultural commodities are going to explode. Inventories of food are the lowest they've been in over 40 years. The number of hectares devoted to wheat farming has been declining for over 30 years.'

Source:
'Commodities: Who's Behind the Boom?', by Gene Epstein, Barron's {$$$}
Rogers Says Sugar, Other Agricultural Commodities to `Explode', by Dave McCombs, Bloomberg News

March 27, 2008

Be A Lazy Investor - Part Two

Earlier I posted about how hard work can actually hurt you as an investor. Most people, those not involved in financial markets, do not have the time, tools, skills or the experience to be really good at picking stocks or mutual funds that consistently beat the market. Even if you do invest in the market, you probably do not make as much as you think due to fees, expenses and taxes.

The Pros Can't Beat Market All The Time

Professional mutual fund managers are not able to consistently beat the market. Here is an excerpt from a Motley Fool on line article on mutual funds,

Though you would think that mutual funds provide benefits to shareholders by hiring alleged "expert" stock pickers, the sad truth of the matter is that the vast majority of mutual funds underperform the average return of the stock market. Over time, because of their costs, approximately 80% of mutual funds will underperform the stock market's returns.

In an article in the FPA Journal, Thomas McGuigan studied the returns of large-cap and mid-cap mutual funds over a period of twenty years. Their conclusion was that very few could consistently beat the market over long time periods. Their study also showed that it was impossible to predict which funds would outperform their index. I guess that is why every investment advertisement says that "...Past performance is not a guarantee for future returns."

Below are tables comparing large-cap and mid-cap with an index fund. The large-cap funds were compared to the Vanguard 500 Index Fund. For mid-caps, there was no mid-cap index fund present over the entire study period, so a proxy index fund was created for the study.

The data in the table reflect four main findings:

  • The longer the investment time frame, the more difficult it was for active managers to outperform the index fund.
  • The percentage of funds that outperformed the index fund over a 20-year period was 10.59 percent.
  • The distinction between returns based on growth, value, and blend styles faded as the investment time frame lengthened.
  • A long-term investor (10-20 years) had a 10.59 percent to 24.71 percent chance of selecting an actively managed fund that outperformed the index fund.

The data in the table reflect four main findings:
  • The longer the investment time frame, the more difficult it was for active managers to compete with the index fund.
  • The percentage of funds that outperformed the index fund over both 15- and 20-year periods was 2.63 percent.
  • The distinction between returns based on growth, value, and blend styles faded as the investment time frame lengthened.
  • A long-term investor (10–20 years) had a 2.63 percent to 13.16 percent chance of selecting an actively managed fund that outperformed the index fund.

How To Beat The Pros

Be lazy, don't invest in individual stocks or actively managed funds. Don't pay attention to Wall Street, CNBC or any Get-Rick-Quick investment schemes.

All you need is a portfolio of just three index funds and you could have beat the S&P 500 last year along with beating it over the past three and five year periods. Below is a chart comparing three portfolios: Second Grader's Starter, S&P 500 and T Rowe Price's 2040 Retirement Mutual Fund. I wanted to throw a retirement/lifestyle fund into the mix to provide a better compassion to the Second Grader's Starter portfolio.

Portfolio

Equity %

1 Year Return (3)

3 Year Annualized Return (3)

5 Year Annualized Return (3)

Second Grader's Starter (1)

90%

8.83%

12.31%

17.02%

S&P 500 (1)

100%

5.49%

8.62%

12.83%

T Rowe Price 2040 Fund (2)

91%

6.67%

10.31%

14.76%

1) Source: Morningstar Inc
2) Source: T Rowe Price
3) Returns as of 01/03/2008

The Second Grader's Starter was developed by Allan Roth, a Colorado Springs CPA, for his 7-year old son in 2004. Allan developed a portfolio of just three Vanguard mutual funds, Total Stock Market Index, Total International Stock Index and the Total Bond Market Index. This portfolio has four huge advantages for it:

  • Owns the entire world and has maximum global diversification;
  • Has less than 0.25 percent annual expenses, both hidden and disclosed;
  • Is extremely tax-efficient, and
  • Automatically re-balances within U.S. and international markets.

The suggested portfolio breaks out as follows, depending on your risk tolerance.

Investment

High Risk (1)

Medium Risk

Low Risk

Vanguard Total Stock Market Index VTSMX

60%

40%

20%

Vanguard Total Intl Stock Index VGTSX

30%

20%

10%

Vanguard Total Bond Market Index VBMFX

10%

40%

70%

Totals

100%

100%

100%

1) This was the fund allocation used in the Second Grader's Starter Portfolio noted above.

Other Lazy Portfolios

In 2004, Paul B Farrell published 'The Lazy Person's Guide to Investing: A Book for Procrastinators, the Financially Challenged, and Everyone Who Worries About Dealing With Their Money', which showed the benefits of a simple, easy to maintain and understand portfolio of mutual index funds. Currently he writes for Marketwatch.com and has been tracking several 'Lazy Portfolios':

Equity Returns for 8 Lazy Portfolios:

Portfolio

Equity %

# of Funds

1 Year Return (1)

3 Year Annualized Return (1)

5 Year Annualized Return (1)

Aronson Family Taxable

80%

11

13.54%

16.23%

21.47%

FundAdvice Ultimate Buy & Hold

60

11

6.93%

14.44%

20.32%

Margaritaville

67

3

10.51%

14.01%

18.63%

Yale U's Unconventional

70

6

2.78%

12.08%

18.12%

Dr. Bernstein's Smart Money

60

9

3.72%

11.43%

17.75%

Dr. Bernstein's No-Brainer

75

4

6.79%

11.59%

17.47%

Second Grader's Starter

90

3

8.83%

12.31%

17.02%

Coffeehouse

60

7

-0.23%

9.75%

16.71%

S&P 500

100

n/a

5.49%

8.62%

12.83%

1) Returns as of 01/03/2008

The portfolios vary in complexity, both in number of funds and in amount of maintenance required, and in returns. One of the main points that gets repeated over an over is to take the emotion out of your investment decisions and re-balance. The article quotes Ted Aronson, AJO Partners' founder and developer of the Aronson Family Taxable portfolio,

Now comes this year's big lesson: Aronson warns that most investors will psychologically resist selling the big winners and buying lesser performers. But that's what re-balancing and "Modern Portfolio Theory" (the theory behind Lazy Portfolios) is all about. You stick to your asset allocations as sector performance waxes and wanes over the long-term. Otherwise you're just chasing hot sectors and engaged in high-risk market-timing

Really Really Lazy Portfolios

For some people, having to invest in three funds and then re-balance every year is still too much work. Not to worry, mutual fund companies have developed Life Style or Target Retirement funds. These funds are a one-stop-funds that invest in a basket of stock and bond mutual funds, shifting overtime from more stocks in the early years to more bonds as the 'target' age is reached. These funds will even re-balance as needed to maintain their asset allocations, all you would need to do is fund the investment.

With this type of investment it is very important to pick a mutual fund company (Fidelity, T Rowe Price or Vanguard) that has low management fees. A minor point to look into is the asset allocation of the funds as there are some differences which may affect returns. See table below for a comparison

Investment

% of Stock

% of Bonds/Cash

Foreign Stocks as a % of Stocks

American Century LIVESTRONG 2035 ARYIX

74.9%

25.1%

15.8%

T. Rowe Price Retirement 2035 TRRJX

87.5%

12.7%

22.4%

1) Source: Morningstar Inc

It Seems So Easy?

It is that easy. Granted there will be people who will say that these portfolios will not work, or that they can't be any good cause they are too simple. The evidence shows that these methods do work, are easy and can be very profitable. As Paul Farrell noted: "Nothing saved ... equals nothing invested ... equals nothing compounded ... equals a less than dreamy retirement".

Source:
"
The Difficulty of Selecting Superior Mutual Fund Performance", Thomas P. McGuigan, CFP, FPA Journal
"
Lazy Portfolios Annual Update For Recssion '08", Paul B. Farrell, Marketwatch.com
"
How An 8-year Old Crafted A Simple Winning 'Lazy' Portfolio", Paul B. Farrell, Marketwatch.com
"
2nd-Grader's Portfolio Takes On Wall Street", Allan Roth, CPA, The Colorado Springs Business Journal